Aye Aye Eyes is the first part of 27th episode of season 2, which first aired on February 18, 1998. In this episode, Dexter meets a creepy eyed girl who refuses to leave him alone after he does something nice to her.
When a little girl with her stuffed bunny, while Dexter was walking down the lane behind her, the little girl was walking by, her stuffed bunny gets snagged and left behind while the girl kept on walking. Dexter trips over the bunny but notices that the bunny belong to the girl. He catches up to the little girl and returns the bunny to her, but when she opened her eyes, Dexter realizes how creepy she is, and then the Creepy Eyed Girl suddenly follows Dexter everywhere he goes even to the point of falling in love with him, until a boy similar to her Creepy Neighborhood Boy, goes out into the sunset.